Taxonomic Notes
Molecular analyses have revealed the existence of distinct northeast Atlantic and Mediterranean evolutionary lineages within this taxon, which probably originated through allopatric isolation during the Pleistocene (Duranton et al. 2018).
Some studies have suggested that these represent semi‐isolated species (i.e., independent lineages in which speciation remains incomplete) rather than differentiated populations of the same taxon. The two lineages hybridise throughout a post-glacial secondary contact zone located in the Alboran Sea, with a sharp divide at the Almeria-Oran Front (AOF). The AOF serves as a barrier by separating colder, less-saline Atlantic waters from the denser Mediterranean (Robinet et al. 2020).
This phenomenon has generated a supplementary layer of genetic subdivision between Sea Bass inhabiting the eastern and western Mediterranean, respectively (Quéré et al. 2012). Additional genetic diversity has been detected within individual Mediterranean basins, e.g., the Adriatic and Levantine seas, and is potentially present in the Black Sea (Souche et al. 2015).
Justification
The global population trend of the European sea bass remains unquantified, but it is estimated to be declining.
While measures are in place to combat documented declines over some of the northeast Atlantic portion of its range, the annual commercial and recreational fishing mortality in this region continues to hover around the maximum sustainable yield. The status of the Mediterranean subpopulation remains unclear, but plausible threats include overfishing, widespread habitat loss, climate change, and genetic introgression with domesticated conspecifics.
Although the species remains widespread, major declines in spawning biomass within the last three generations have been confirmed throughout the northern part of its range and have plausibly occurred elsewhere. It is therefore assessed as Near Threatened under Criterion A (A2bcde).
Geographic Range Information
This species inhabits the continental shelves of the northeast Atlantic Ocean from Morocco to Norway, including the British Isles, plus the Mediterranean and southern Black Sea basins. There are occasional records of vagrant individuals from the Baltic Sea and Atlantic coastline of North Africa as far south as Senegal. Recent records suggest that it has invaded the northern Red Sea basin via the Suez Canal.
Population Information
This species' global population trend has not been quantified, but ongoing threats throughout its range are estimated to be driving a general decline. The overall population size might also be affected by extended periods of enhanced or reduced recruitment which appear to be related to changes in sea temperature, particularly in the northeast Atlantic.
Intensive exploitation around the British Isles during the late 1970s and 1980s led to a major decrease in landings, but management measures implemented in 1990 resulted in partial recovery.
The northeast Atlantic subpopulation is currently subdivided into four individual stocks by the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES), an intergovernmental marine science organisation which advises the European Union (EU). According to ICES data the biomass of spawning individuals belonging to the northern stock (which inhabits the North Sea, English Channel, Irish Sea and Celtic Sea) has declined significantly since 2009 and reached its lowest point for 20 years in 2013, while recruitment has been low without a clear trend since 2008. The southern stock (Bay of Biscay), appears more stable but a decreasing trend in spawning stock biomass has been detected since 2010. At time of writing, population trends of the remaining two northeast Atlantic stocks (comprising Southern Ireland/Western Scotland and Portugal/northern Spain, respectively) and the Mediterranean subpopulation are unclear.
Habitat and Ecology Information
The European sea bass inhabits shallow (typically <100 metres depth) coastal waters. It is euryhaline (0-40 ppt salinity) and eurythermal (2-32°C). Adults forage in estuaries, coastal lagoons, harbours and the lower reaches of rivers from spring to autumn. During winter adults migrate up to several hundred kilometres from coastlines to deeper waters, where the temperature is more stable.
It is is characterised by slow growth and late maturity. Males attain sexual maturity at four to seven years of age and females at five to eight years of age depending on subpopulation, with both sexes maturing earlier in the Mediterranean. Young individuals are gregarious and form schools, whereas adults are more solitary but form offshore spawning aggregations from December to March in the Mediterranean and January to June in the Atlantic.
Adults exhibit fidelity to particular foraging and spawning sites, implying that the overall population is spatially-structured. Females produce an average of 200,000 eggs/kg, which are fertilised externally. Eggs hatch after three to five days, and larvae (measuring 4 mm at hatching) reach the post‐larval stage (22 mm) in two to three months while migrating to inshore nursery areas such as estuaries and lagoons. This species is an adaptable and opportunistic predator, feeding on plankton at the larval stage and on other fishes and crustaceans at the juvenile and adult stages. Experimental evidence suggests it is able to adopt different feeding strategies in order to exploit a range of environments, possibly in response to tidal conditions.
Threats Information
Ongoing anthropogenic degradation of coastal wetlands due to pollution or drainage for agricultural, industrial and urban development has driven a reduction in the extent and quality of coastal aquatic environments throughout this species' range. These issues may be driving localised declines given its fidelity to particular foraging and nursery sites.
Moreover, its relatively predictable behaviour patterns, whereby it forms spawning aggregations at known offshore sites in winter before moving inshore to feed at other times of the year, makes it vulnerable to exploitation by both inshore and offshore fisheries. In the northeast Atlantic, overharvesting of the northern and southern stocks remains a major threat despite recent management measures (see 'Conservation'). In addition, illegal, unreported, and unregulated landings are known to be widespread in this region.
In the Mediterranean basin, expanding sea-pen aquaculture has resulted in cultured individuals escaping into the wild. These display differences in both phenotype and genetic structure compared with natural subpopulations, and have raised concerns of introgression and disease transmission.
Climate change also appears to be exerting an influence on population dynamics, with the species expanding further into the North Atlantic.
Use and Trade Information
The European sea bass is a highly-valued delicacy in many European countries and elsewhere, with intra-EU trade particularly important. Wild-caught sea bass fetch the highest prices, and in the northeast Atlantic they are harvested by fishing fleets from France, Spain, the UK and, to a lesser extent, Belgium and the Netherlands. From 2010-2019 it was the most expensive fish on average among major commercial species in the northeast Atlantic region, comprising on average 10% of the landing value of small-scale fleets, and up to 50% for some vessels in the Netherlands. Smaller vessels using hooks and line are usually able sell the fish at higher prices than trawlers due to their perceived greater quality and sustainable landing methods.
France and the UK represent the largest markets with a final price of up to €35/kg in the former country as of 2020. In the Mediterranean it accounts for c. 5% of small-scale fleet landing value, with an average final price of €22/kg. Harvesting of wild individuals only accounts for <10% of global production, however, since the species is farmed intensively throughout the Mediterranean basin. It was the first non‐salmonid marine species to be commercially cultured in Europe, and in countries such as Italy and Spain it has long been reared by methods which involve trapping the fish inside coastal lagoons and allowing them to feed naturally until they are harvested.
By the 1980s hatchery techniques were widely established and these have today largely replaced such traditional procedures. In most cases the fish are cultivated in floating cages, although some farms employ land-based tanks. The EU is the largest producer of farmed sea bass with a market share of c. 80% worth €504 million in 2018, while Egypt and Türkiye are also significant contributors. Within the EU, Greece is the most important producer, followed by Spain, Italy and to a lesser extent, France and Portugal. A number of dedicated aquaculture facilities also operate in the UK.
Recreational fisheries also play an important role in the exploitation of all stocks, with the socio-economic value of recreational sea bass fishing in the EU and UK estimated to exceed €200 million per year.
Conservation Actions Information
In the northeast Atlantic this species is not covered by the EU's Common Fisheries Policy. It was managed at the national level until 2015, when the EU Commission introduced a series of emergency measures to curb declines in the northern stock. These rules cover both commercial and recreational fishing and included strict monthly catch limits, daily bag limits, closed seasons and an increase in minimum landing size. They have generated considerable controversy and conflict between the commercial and recreational fishing sectors, leading to inconsistencies in their implementation.
Overall commercial and recreational fishing mortality for the northern stock has fallen below the maximum sustainable yield as a result of the measures, although spawning biomass remains low. As of 2020 the EU continues to adjust the measures on an annual basis based on independent scientific advice issued by ICES. The southern stock is managed by France for commercial fisheries and the EU for recreational anglers, with catch and daily bag limit allowances slightly greater than for the northern stock.
In the Mediterranean Sea a minimum landing size is in place, but this subpopulation is not otherwise managed for conservation purposes, and studies regarding its status are urgently required.
Research published to date recommends that the genetic diversity identified both between and within the Atlantic and Mediterranean stocks should be taken into account when planning any future management efforts.